The Economic Definition of Money and Bitcoin's Functional Gap

To determine whether Bitcoin is money, one must first compare it against the classical definitions of "money" in mainstream macroeconomics and monetary economics. In modern economics, for an item to be widely accepted and classified as money, it generally must simultaneously fulfill three core functions: a medium of exchange, a unit of account, and a store of value. A deep examination of Bitcoin's actual operational status across these three dimensions reveals significant differences from traditional fiat currency.

Financial editorial illustration

In terms of a medium of exchange, although Bitcoin supports decentralized peer-to-peer global transfers and is used for goods and services transactions in certain specific scenarios or among geek communities, its adoption in the global real economy and daily commercial retail remains extremely low. Due to transaction confirmation times, network throughput, and rapid price volatility, the vast majority of merchants and consumers do not use it as a routine pricing and payment tool. Regarding a unit of account, almost all global commodities, labor, asset valuations, as well as national finances and corporate financial reports are denominated in fiat currencies (such as the US dollar, Euro, RMB, etc.), and Bitcoin cannot serve as a stable yardstick for measuring economic value. As for a store of value, while proponents view it as "digital gold" to hedge against inflation due to its fixed total supply, its price has experienced multiple crashes of over 50% or even 80% across historical cycles. This extremely high volatility prevents it from meeting the basic requirements of risk-averse individuals for a stable store of value. Therefore, central banks and academic institutions in multiple countries, including the Federal Reserve, the European Central Bank, and the Reserve Bank of Australia, generally believe that Bitcoin does not meet the strict economic definition of money, and is closer to a high-risk speculative digital asset or alternative investment target.

Legal Attributes, Sovereign Credit, and Legal Tender Status

Beyond economic functions, from the perspective of legal attributes and national sovereignty, money is essentially an extension of national sovereignty and legal credit. Fiat currency in modern economy is issued by a national central bank and endowed with "legal tender" status backed by state coercive power, meaning the law mandates that all debt settlements, tax payments, and commodity transactions within the country must accept the fiat currency. This legal tender status ensures the absolute circulation and universal acceptance of currency within its sovereign jurisdiction.

In contrast, as a decentralized cryptographic digital asset, Bitcoin does not rely on any national sovereignty, central bank, or government credit, and has no entity backing it or providing a backstop guarantee. Consequently, it lacks legal tender status in the vast majority of countries and regions. For instance, regulatory agencies such as the People's Bank of China have explicitly stated that Bitcoin does not have the same legal status as statutory currency and belongs to a specific virtual commodity; the European Central Bank and multiple financial regulatory authorities have also repeatedly emphasized that it cannot be used as official currency. Although a very small number of countries like El Salvador have granted it legal tender status within specific regions through legislation, this is an exception in the global financial system and has not changed the international community's positioning of its non-sovereign attribute. Due to the lack of legal tender protection, ordinary residents cannot enjoy the state-legal protection of debt settlement when holding and using Bitcoin, which further limits its path toward evolving into traditional currency.

Technological and Economic Characteristics: Digital Scarcity and Practical Limitations

From the perspective of technology and underlying economic models, Bitcoin was not originally designed to replicate traditional central bank fiat currency, but rather to build a decentralized, cryptography-based digital value transfer network. Through the Proof-of-Work (PoW) consensus mechanism and a distributed blockchain ledger, it solves the "double-spending" problem in the digital world and achieves peer-to-peer value transfer without trusting a third-party intermediary.

In terms of economic characteristics, Bitcoin adopts a hard-coded supply cap of 21 million coins and a halving mechanism approximately every four years, possessing natural anti-inflation and tamper-proof attributes. Supporters believe this mechanism endows it with scarce value similar to gold. However, from the perspective of the money supply regulation mechanism, traditional bank money is essentially credit money based on debt liability relationships, and central banks can flexibly adjust monetary policy and supply according to cyclical changes in the macroeconomy (such as economic recession or inflation) to play a role in smoothing economic fluctuations. In contrast, because Bitcoin lacks an elastic supply regulation mechanism, it cannot stabilize the macroeconomy through expansion or contraction when facing economic tightening or liquidity crises. This "hard deflation" characteristic instead makes its price vulnerable to shocks from market speculative sentiment and liquidity cycles, further undermining its viability as a daily circulating currency.